Aroma molecule · acid
butanoic acid
Smells ofrancid, cheesy, sweaty, butter, sour
Found in 100 ingredients; measured in 6 of them and clearly above the level you can smell in cream.
Working on a formulation or a product line? This compound data is available by API for R&D teams.
Where you’d actually smell it
Each food placed by its measured amount of butanoic acid divided by the smallest amount people can smell (1510 ppb, our working threshold). Past 1× it may be noticeable; this is a screening indicator, since the food’s matrix and its other aromas shift what you actually smell. 6 of the foods we list have a measured value; 3 are above the line.
Scroll sideways to see the whole ruler →
Only foods we hold butanoic acid in and have a measured concentration for are placed. Every measured row, with its source, is in the table below.
01How little it takes
- in waterpapers disagree 1,000
- in a foodpapers disagree 650
- in alcohol 964
- in wine/beerpapers disagree 173
- in oil 135
- in starch 100
Parts per billion (ppb), log scale · tick = median of published values, bar = full range, from open-access paper tables (not reviewed)
02Where it turns up
- Dairy24
- Fruit14
- Meat & fish13
- Drinks11
- Grains, nuts & fats7
- Vegetables4
- Herbs & spices2
- Other25
of the 100 ingredients that contain it, by food group
03What it travels with
line weight = ingredients carrying both, of 100 · only molecules found with it at least 1.5× as often as across all foods
What does butanoic acid smell like?
Sources describe it as rancid, cheesy, sweaty, butter, sour. The key-food-odorant survey gives sweaty, cheesy.
It is a key food odorant (generalist): identified in the meta-analysis of 227 food samples as one of 16 generalist odorants, which appear in more than 25% of foods, typically from generic Maillard, lipid-oxidation or fermentation pathways. Source: Dunkel et al. 2014, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 53, 7124–7143
How this molecule is described
Also filed as: butyric acid — same molecule, unified here.
- rancid, cheesy, sweaty Flavornet Cas
- fatty FlavorDB 2.0, Flavordb Odor Column 2 sources agree
- corn FlavorDB 2.0, Flavordb Odor Column 2 sources agree
- onion, cooked FlavorDB 2.0, Flavordb Odor Column 2 sources agree
- apple, banana, burnt, orange, rancid, waxy FlavorDB 2.0
- sweaty FlavorDB 2.0
About these descriptions
Ordered by how many independent descriptor streams give each wording, then by how often it appears. The bar is replication (one source copied onto many ingredients scores high), not corroboration.Which foods contain butanoic acid?
We list 100 ingredients that contain it, but presence is not the same as smell. What matters is how much is there compared with how little it takes to notice it. That ratio is the odour activity value (OAV). Above 1 suggests it may be noticeable; it is a screening indicator, not a guarantee.
- Clearly there (10× or more): cream.
- Faint (1–10×): cheese, beef.
- Present but below the threshold: lamb, milk, baijiu.
Found in
Measured foods first, then real food profiles, then thin or composite records (marked). The figure beside each is how many compounds that ingredient has in total, not the amount of butanoic acid in it. ✓n = sources that recorded the link.
- cream measured · 47× threshold 71 cmpds
- cheese measured · 9.9× threshold ✓2 285 cmpds
- beef measured · 3.3× threshold ✓1 429 cmpds
- lamb measured · 0.61× threshold 261 cmpds
- milk measured · 0.54× threshold 346 cmpds
- baijiu measured · 0.51× threshold 200 cmpds
- ranch dairy 22 cmpds
- halloumi dairy 24 cmpds
Measured concentrations
| Food | Concentration (ppb) | OAV | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| coffee | 200,000.0 | 132 | PMID 34421873 |
| white wine | 150,000.0 | 99.3 | DOI |
| cream | 71,000.0 | 47.0 | PMID 39045299 |
| carrot | 38,715.0 | 25.6 | — |
| cheese | 15,000.0 | 9.93 | Corpus paper |
| beef | 5,000.0 | 3.31 | Corpus paper |
| whey | 2,550.0 | 1.69 | — |
| wine | 1,839.0 | 1.22 | Corpus paper |
| cucumber | 1,400.0 | 0.93 | Corpus paper |
| lamb | 920.0 | 0.61 | Corpus paper |
| milk | 816.0 | 0.54 | Corpus paper |
| peanut | 795.1 | 0.53 | Corpus paper |
| baijiu | 775.0 | 0.51 | PMID 41190275 |
| beans | 63.7 | 0.04 | DOI |
| garlic | 60.0 | 0.04 | Corpus paper |
| goat milk | 50.0 | 0.03 | DOI |
| tea | 50.5 | 0.03 | Corpus paper |
| pear | 20.0 | 0.01 | Corpus paper |
| lime | 9.7 | 0.01 | Corpus paper |
| olive oil | 2.3 | 0.00 | — |
OAV = measured concentration ÷ odour threshold (1510.0 ppb, the engine’s working value — see the 15 published values). OAV ≥ 1 suggests it may be perceptible; treat it as a screening indicator. Concentrations from open-access papers; a row whose food is not one of the ingredients above is listed here but not placed on the ruler.
How strong is butanoic acid?
Orthonasal, in clean water: 240 ppb to 2400 ppb, median 620 ppb, from 3 published values.
Published thresholds
15 measured values from the literature, grouped by what was measured: a threshold smelled in clean water, tasted, or measured in a real food are different quantities and are not pooled.
| Threshold | Matrix | Source | Paper |
|---|---|---|---|
| 240 ppb | water (food: reference standard (water)) | Literature corpus | — |
| 620 ppb | water | Rychlik 1998 · 4 studies | — |
| 2400 ppb | water (food: reference standard (water)) | Literature corpus | — |
| Threshold | Matrix | Source | Paper |
|---|---|---|---|
| 7700 ppb | water (food: beef vegetable gravy) | Literature corpus | — |
| 7700 ppb | water (food: pork vegetable gravy) | Literature corpus | — |
| Threshold | Matrix | Source | Paper |
|---|---|---|---|
| 6200 ppb | water_retronasal | Rychlik 1998 · 3 studies | — |
| Threshold | Matrix | Source | Paper |
|---|---|---|---|
| 100 ppb | starch | Rychlik 1998 · 1 study | — |
| 135 ppb | oil_orthonasal | Rychlik 1998 · 1 study | — |
| 135 ppb | oil (sunflower oil) (food: gouda cheese) | Literature corpus | — |
| 135 ppb | oil (sunflower oil) (food: cocoa beans) | Literature corpus | — |
| 135 ppb | oil (sunflower oil) (food: cocoa powder) | Literature corpus | — |
| 200 ppb | wine (food: red wine (cabernet sauvignon)) | Literature corpus | — |
| 480 ppb | wine matrix (12% ethanol) (food: rum / red wine) | Literature corpus | — |
| 1200 ppb | ethanol/water (food: rum / red wine) | Literature corpus | — |
| 1200 ppb | ethanol/water 40/60 (food: rum (aged)) | Literature corpus | — |
Values marked “Literature corpus” come from our paper-mining corpus, which records one pooled list of papers for them rather than the paper behind each value: PMID 30779560, PMID 11272845, PMID 19753606 +15 more.
About these numbers
Only values we can attribute are listed. Where a compendium’s licence does not permit public attribution its figures are omitted, so every number here traces to a citable source.More thresholds, from open-access paper tables (not reviewed)
| Medium | Median | Range | Values | Papers | Papers agree? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| air | 964 µg/L air | 50–3.14e+03 | 9 | 7 | yes |
| ethanol solution | 964 ppb | 173–9.88e+03 | 11 | 9 | yes |
| food matrix | 650 ppb | 0.732–1.73e+05 | 43 | 40 | no (2.3 decades) |
| model wine or beer | 173 ppb | 173–173 | 1 | 1 | one paper |
| not applicable | 173 ppb | 173–173 | 1 | 1 | one paper |
| oil | 135 ppb | 34–2.4e+05 | 7 | 6 | yes |
| starch or other | 100 ppb | 100–100 | 3 | 3 | yes |
| unstated | 650 ppb | 0.001–2.4e+05 | 82 | 67 | yes |
| water | 1000 ppb | 0.001–7.7e+03 | 42 | 39 | no (2.9 decades) |
Numbers printed in open-access papers, grouped by the medium the table states. Median and full range; “agree” means two or more papers whose middle 80% of values sit within 100×. Not reviewed.
- Volatility
- high
- Retention index
- 861
What is it found with?
Of the 100 ingredients that carry butanoic acid, 70 also carry nonanoic acid, 67 isovaleric acid and 63 1-hexanol. These are the most frequent companions among molecules that turn up with butanoic acid at least 1.5 times as often as they do across all foods; the very common molecules found nearly everywhere are left out because they say nothing about it.
Is butanoic acid safe to eat?
Butanoic acid is listed by FEMA as generally recognized as safe (GRAS) for use as a flavoring: FEMA number 2221, published in GRAS 3. Check current FDA and EFSA guidance for your market and use level.
- FEMA number
- 2221 ✓ exact match
- Publication
- GRAS 3
- FEMA name
- BUTYRIC ACID (matched on butyric acid, another name for this molecule)
Use-level matrix not extracted for this substance; check the source publication for current ppm guidance.
Source: FEMA GRAS publications 1–33.
See all 100 ingredients with Pro
The free page shows the first 8. The inverted compound index is a Pro feature: reverse-search any of 5,133 flavor molecules across the full graph.
Look up another compound — search by name, CAS number, PubChem CID, or FEMA #.
The Sunday pairing: one pairing, the chemistry behind it, and how to cook it. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
Prefer an account? Create a free account for sign-in; Pro adds the full results and chemistry.
Try the pairing tools to see which ingredient combinations rely on butanoic acid, or compare two ingredients side by side.
Cite this analysis
CompKitchen (2026). butanoic acid compound data sheet. https://compkitchen.com/compound/butanoic%20acid. Accessed 2026-11-22.
@misc{compkitchen_compound_butanoic_acid_compound_data_sheet_2026,
title = {butanoic acid compound data sheet},
author = {{CompKitchen}},
year = {2026},
url = {https://compkitchen.com/compound/butanoic%20acid},
note = {Accessed: 2026-11-22}
}
Methodology DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.19719458 · CC BY 4.0 · Citations are a request, not a requirement.