Why it works: Allspice and clove match in chemistry and in kitchens. They rank in the top 1% of all ingredient pairs, and 7,711 recipes mention both. Both carry methyleugenol, which smells clove, spice. The science ↓
The recipe
Ingredients
Contains: fish (auto-detected from the ingredients and method; we can miss things, so check labels)
Directions
Prepare the fish
Select the largest and roundest herring, wash them in saltwater, and remove the eyes and gills.
Wipe the fish, lay them open at the back, and clean out the insides.
Make the pickle and cure
Prepare a pickle by boiling 5 quarts of water with ½ lb coarse sea salt, 1 lb coarse sugar, 2 oz ground allspice, 15 shredded bay leaves, and 6 shredded laurel leaves for 20 minutes, then strain.
Soak the fish in the pickle for 6 hours.
Dry, smoke and finish
Hang the fish by their shoulders, opened up, to dry in a quick current of air.
Once dried, smoke the fish until they are a fine bright brown.
Return the fish to the air, then lay them on their backs and brush the insides with a mixture of 2 parts essence of allspice and 1 part water.
Repeat brushing with the mixture of essences (cassia, cloves, mace, bays) and water 3 to 4 times, according to taste.
Cook to a safe temperature. This method doesn't say how hot the inside should get. Check with a food thermometer in the thickest part:
- Fish: 145°F (63°C), or until the flesh is opaque and flakes easily.
Figures from the USDA's safe minimum internal temperatures.
Transcribed from a scanned cookbook and modernised for today's kitchens. Where the book gave no heat or time, or said "a moderate oven", the temperatures and times here may be modern equivalents rather than the book's own figures.
Found this recipe through an AI assistant? CompKitchen also shows which ingredients go well together and why, from the aroma molecules they share and how often recipes combine them. Try the pairing tools.
Explore the science
The flavor team
The pairs that carry this dish. Each one is judged two ways: how much aroma chemistry they share, and how many recipes mention both.
-
Allspice + clovetop 1% of all pairsAroma overlapstrongMentioned together7,711 recipes
Shared aroma: methyleugenol (clove, spice).
-
Cassia + clovetop 1% of all pairsAroma overlapstrongMentioned together190 recipes
Shared aroma: ethyl cinnamate (sweet, balsamic).
-
Laurel + clovetop 1% of all pairsAroma overlapstrongMentioned together2,941 recipes
Shared aroma: methyleugenol (clove, spice).
-
Clove + macetop 2% of all pairsAroma overlapmoderateMentioned together8,199 recipes
Shared aroma: methyleugenol (clove, spice).
-
Allspice + macetop 2% of all pairsAroma overlapstrongMentioned together3,189 recipes
Shared aroma: methyleugenol (clove, spice).
Ranks compare each pair with 20,000 random ingredient pairs on CompKitchen. How we score pairs
What each ingredient does
- Herring
- Forms the main body of the dish, carrying the flavour of the pickle and smoke.
- Coarse sea salt
- Draws moisture out of the fish and seasons it during the pickle soak.
- Coarse sugar
- Balances the salt in the pickle and adds a mild sweetness to the fish.
- Ground allspice
- Adds warm, aromatic spice flavour to the pickle.
The step that matters
Drying the fish in a quick current of air before smoking. Smoke sticks and colours the surface best when it is dry; damp fish smoke unevenly and can turn dull or sour. Drying forms a tacky surface that takes smoke well.
Flavor stand-ins for the mace
How well each one fits the dish's main ingredients (sugar, allspice, laurel, cassia, clove):
- Cinnamonbetter flavor fit
- Cardamombetter flavor fit
- Gingerbetter flavor fit
- Macethe original
Fit is the average pairing score against sugar, allspice, laurel, cassia, clove. Candidates are from the same food group and used in at least 100 recipes. This compares flavor only: it does not check the job the ingredient does in the dish (bulk, moisture, acidity, structure).
“What each ingredient does” and “The step that matters” were written by Claude, an AI, from this recipe’s own method. They are not checked recipe by recipe, so they can be wrong.
Make it your own
Stand-ins, a drink, and quick taste fixes for this dish, ranked by how well each fits its other ingredients: shared aroma molecules and how often recipes combine them.
You might also like
The Sunday pairing: one pairing, the chemistry behind it, and how to cook it. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
Prefer an account? Create a free account for sign-in; Pro adds the full results and chemistry.
Illustration
Illustration
Illustration
Illustration